Liz Truss became the U.K. Prime Minister on Sept. 6 as the country prepares for a possible recession in Q4.European Central Bank has increased interest rates by 75bps, a record, but they are still way behind the inflation curve at 9.1%The market is pricing in a 75bps rate hike in the September FOMC meeting as the most likely outcome due to the tight labor marketRussia indefinitely suspends Nord Stream gas pipeline to EuropeGazprom and CNPC agree on the transition to making payments for gas supplies to China in Rubles and YuanBitcoin dropped below $20,000 for the first time since early JulyBitcoin’s correlation to the S&P 500 remains strongRussia is working with several friendly countries on cross-border settlements in stablecoins
Economy in peril
Liz Truss took charge as prime minister amid a potential recession from double-digit inflation and record increases in the cost of living. She is at the helm of a government with deteriorating finances, partly due to the sterling at a 37-year low and soaring payments on index-linked gilts.
Truss has promised tax cuts and additional stimulus checks — a £130 billion plan to freeze U.K. power bills and choke inflation, most likely leading to higher long-term inflation.
As gilt yields continued to climb higher at the front end, the 2-year gilt rose to a 14-year high, and the 10-year gilt climbed past 3% for the first time since 2014.
U.K. 2 & 10 Year Bond Yield: (Source: TradingView)
A subsidy of £130 billion to keep household energy bills below £2,500 equals roughly 5% of the U.K. GDP. Such a hefty subsidy will likely increase energy prices, drive up business sectors’ costs, and cause corporate debt yields to soar.
Sterling investment-grade yield: (Source: Bloomberg)
Europe struggles on
Europe continues to limp on following the ECB’s latest 75 bps interest rate hike. The euro is battling to get above parity against the U.S. dollar.
Investor confidence in the eurozone showed little to no improvement, as the Sentix survey shows a decline of almost 7 points to -31.8 — similar levels seen during the covid pandemic and the 2008 financial crisis.
Leaders around the eurozone are discussing aid packages; Germany is preparing a $65 billion inflation relief package, which requires massive debt monetization from the ECB to contain spreads and ease conditions, leading to more debasement.
Eurozone Sentix Investor Confidence. (Source: The Daily Shot)
A zombie apocalypse
Nearly 25% of U.S. businesses are “zombie companies.” The previous record for zombies was 17%, set back in 2001. These companies have survived off near-zero interest rates and don’t generate cash to pay interest on their debts. They are a result of artificially low yields in the U.S.
It would be pretty hard for these companies to survive in a rising yield environment, which would end up triggering mass unemployment.
Currently, the unemployment rate is 3.7%. A double-digit unemployment rate was last seen during the recessions caused by the 2008 housing crash and covid.
According to Jim Walker, chief economist at Aletheia Capital:
“If the markets determined the interest rates then you would have never gone to the levels of zero interest rates that central bankers have been pushing that ended ensuing zombie companies.”
Federal Funds Effective Rate. (Source: FRED)Zombie. (Source: The Leuthold Group)
Equities & Volatility Gauge
The Standard and Poor’s 500, or simply the S&P 500, is a stock market index tracking the stock performance of 500 large companies listed on exchanges in the United States. S&P 500 4,067 4% (7D)
The Nasdaq Stock Market is an American stock exchange based in New York City. It is ranked second on the list of stock exchanges by market capitalization of shares traded, behind the New York Stock Exchange. NASDAQ 12,681 4% (7D)
The Cboe Volatility Index, or VIX, is a real-time market index representing the market’s expectations for volatility over the coming 30 days. Investors use the VIX to measure the level of risk, fear, or stress in the market when making investment decisions. VIX 23 -9% (7D)
S&P and Bitcoin tied at the hip
Fed speakers tried to talk the equities market down during the week commencing Sept. 5 and only made things worse as equities marched higher.
The FOMC meeting slated for late September currently has an 86% probability of a 75 basis point hike rate.
U.S. equities continue to remain tightly correlated with BTC. For most of 2022, Bitcoin and the S&P500 have been in a tight correlation with one another. Currently, the S&P500 is 19% off its all-time high, but if stocks fall, we expect to see new lows for Bitcoin.
S&P vs Bitcoin. (Source: TradingView)
The demand for gold is determined by the amount of gold in the central bank reserves, the value of the U.S. dollar, and the desire to hold gold as a hedge against inflation and currency devaluation, all help drive the price of the precious metal. Gold Price $1,724 1.0% (7D)
Similar to most commodities, the silver price is determined by speculation and supply and demand. It is also affected by market conditions (large traders or investors and short selling), industrial, commercial, and consumer demand, hedge against financial stress, and gold prices. Silver Price $19 5.8% (7D)
The price of oil, or the oil price, generally refers to the spot price of a barrel (159 litres) of benchmark crude oil. Crude Oil Price $87 -1.5% (7D)
Move over ESG, demand for coal is soaring
Asia Coal Futures. (Source: TradingView)Last week, we observed the energy futures market, this week it’s coal futures. The price of coal in Asia (spot Newcastle benchmark) surged to an all-time high of $440 per metric tonne. The graph observes the future price for October, November and December 2022. Coal prices in Asia rally to a record as the global hunt for fuel escalates. Utilities look to coal to replace liquified natural gas which has become too expensive to obtain.
Spot physical coal loaded at Australia’s Newcastle port was priced at $436.71/ton, a record. That’s nearly triple the price this time last year.Newcastle futures for October jumped 5% to $463.75/ton Monday, the highest price in data stretching back to January 2016
How much have energy prices increaased in the last year:
European natural gas futures: +335% Asian LNG spot: +255% European coal futures: +180% Asian coal spot: +157%
Rates & Currency
The 10-year Treasury note is a debt obligation issued by the United States government with a maturity of 10 years upon initial issuance. A 10-year Treasury note pays interest at a fixed rate once every six months and pays the face value to the holder at maturity. 10Y Treasury Yield 3.3% 3% (7D)
The U.S. dollar index is a measure of the value of the U.S. dollar relative to a basket of foreign currencies. DXY 107.8 -1.65% (7D)
USDJPY chart in focus
The USD/JPY chart continues to make multi-decade highs, currently at 142 and climbing. The Bank of Japan (BOJ) is currently at 230% debt to GDP and a 9% deficit, and the hammer blow is that the BOJ owns 50% of government debt.
Japan is the world’s largest foreign holder of U.S. treasuries ($1.2 trillion); with a weakening yen, Japan has a further incentive to sell U.S. treasuries to defend the yen, and those sales are made to pay for energy. The yield curve control by the BOJ, not allowing the 10-year treasury to yield more than 0.25% (25bps), is causing additional pressure on the Yen.
As of Sep. 7, the 10-year yield went above 0.25%, and BOJ is forced to buy bonds with freshly printed yen to pay for supplies. Investors will have to sell bonds to avoid being paid back in depreciating yen, all while yields continue to go up further as bonds sell-off.
Japanese Government Bond and Yen. (Source: TradingView)
The decline in the Yen will have ripple effects throughout the global economy, as Japan is the fourth largest exporter in the world. The Real Narrow Effective Exchange Rate for Japan is at levels not seen since 1973. These sorts of moves take time to show up in asset pricing.
Real Narrow Effective Exchange Rate for Japan. (Source: FRED)
What’s the effect, and does it affect Bitcoin?
September is the first month of full-scale quantitative tightening by the fed, which means lower demand for U.S. treasuries, coinciding with Japan and Asia FX being down. Lower demand for USTs will equal higher U.S. bond yields and risk assets suffering.
Due to rising bond yields, this could potentially force the Fed to consider yield curve control. However, another way is for the Fed to purchase Japanese government bonds to take pressure off the BOJ.
Bond bulls trapped, debt spiral accelerates
According to Investopedia, TLT is a high-quality ETF, thanks to a low expense ratio and liquidity. However, during this global deleveraging event that is occurring, bonds have been slaughtered. As the fed continues to ramp up Q.T. and the 10-year treasury pushes up towards 4%+. This translates to a debt service replacement cost of $1.2 trillion — 3x the current annual interest expense. Therefore, the U.S. is operating in a deficit as the federal debt to GDP is at 137%.
The Fed has two options, pivot and lower rates and resume quantitative easing — kicking the can down the proverbial road — or continue to let inflation hotter than 2%, raise GDP and monetize the debt.
The time frame is unknown how long this can last but politicians and governments have usually opted to kick the can down the road.
TLT vs 10-Year Treasury Yield. (Source: TradingView)
The price of Bitcoin (BTC) in USD. Bitcoin Price $22,040 10.60% (7D)
The measure of Bitcoin’s total market cap against the larger cryptocurrency market cap. Bitcoin Dominance 39.29% 1.28% (7D)
Price OHLC. (Source: Glassnode)
From Sept. 5 onwards, Bitcoin has been trading below the realized price which is $21,500
Russia is working with several friendly countries on cross-border settlements in stablecoins
Beijing-based mining pool Poolin has suspended withdrawals from its wallet citing liquidity issues. Currently, 10% of the bitcoin hash rate points to the Poolin mining pool.
On Sep. 8, the Climate and energy implications of crypto-assets in the U.S. got released by the white house
Bitcoin closed Sept. 6 at $18,849 down 72.6% drop from its all-time high and the lowest close of a day in 2022
Price Drawdown from ATH. (Source: Glassnode)
Collection of core address metrics for the network.
The number of unique addresses that were active in the network either as a sender or receiver. Only addresses that were active in successful transactions are counted. Active Addresses 934,803 0.64% (7D)
The number of unique addresses that appeared for the first time in a transaction of the native coin in the network. New Addresses 2,868,464 3.28% (7D)
The number of unique addresses holding 1 BTC or less. Addresses with ≥ 1 BTC 901,681 0.18% (7D)
The number of unique addresses holding at least 1k BTC. Addresses with Balance ≤ 1k BTC 2,140 -0.28% (7D)
Accumulation addresses continue its vertical trajectory
The number of unique accumulation addresses continues to reach all-time highs. Accumulation addresses are addresses with at least 2 incoming non-dust transfers and never spent funds. Exchange addresses and addresses received from Coinbase transactions (miner addresses) are discarded. To account for lost coins, addresses that were last active more than 7 years ago are omitted as well.
During the 2017 bull run, accumulation addresses went parabolic, with an increase of over 200,000 addresses. However, a similar trend is occurring for 2022, with an increase of 200,000 addresses. But, the price has regressed since the start of the year. Addresses continue accumulating BTC through severe macro uncertainty and a lot of negative price action, but what is encouraging to see that many different cohorts are accumulating albeit at different levels. This year, a lot of selling has occurred mainly from liquidations and capitulation from short-term holders, which will be explained later in the newsletter.
Accumulation Addresses. (Source: Glassnode)
Entity-adjusted metrics use proprietary clustering algorithms to provide a more precise estimate of the actual number of users in the network and measure their activity.
The number of unique entities that were active either as a sender or receiver. Entities are defined as a cluster of addresses that are controlled by the same network entity and are estimated through advanced heuristics and Glassnode’s proprietary clustering algorithms. Active Entities 253,203 5.23% (7D)
The number of BTC in the Purpose Bitcoin ETF. Purpose ETF Holdings 23,679 -0.37% (7D)
The number of unique entities holding at least 1k BTC. Number of Whales 1,700 -0.64% (7D)
The total amount of BTC held on OTC desk addresses. OTC Desk Holdings 4,119 BTC 8.80% (7D)
Whales continue to sell, while retail accumulates
Whales are defined by glassnode as an entity that holds 1,000 BTC or more. The graph below depicts the net position change of whales — when whales buy and sell. You can see when whales sold (red) in May 2021 and May 2022, the price dropped significantly. Conversely, when whales purchase BTC, it also has a significant relationship with price appreciation. However, much of 2022 has seen whales distribute heavily, most notably after the Terra Luna collapse.
Whale Net Position Change. (Source: Glassnode)
As whales continue to sell their BTC holdings, retail is one of the main entities continuing to accumulate. Retail holds almost 3 million BTC compared to whales’ 9 million BTC. However, we can see a clear trend of exponential growth of retail holdings, which is a net positive for the adoption and distribution of BTC as it’s concentrated in fewer hands which is one of the many criticisms of Bitcoin.
Retail vs. Whales. (Source: Glassnode)
A derivative is a contract between two parties which derives its value/price from an underlying asset. The most common types of derivatives are futures, options and swaps. It is a financial instrument which derives its value/price from the underlying assets.
The total amount of funds (USD Value) allocated in open futures contracts. Futures Open Interest $12.56B 9.36% (7D)
The total volume (USD Value) traded in futures contracts in the last 24 hours. Futures Volume $21.8B $23.49 (7D)
The sum liquidated volume (USD Value) from short positions in futures contracts. Total Long Liquidations $129.34M $65.39M (7D)
The sum liquidated volume (USD Value) from long positions in futures contracts. Total Short Liquidations $112.77M $75.77M (7D)
The all-time high for futures and perpetual open interest – brace for volatility
The Futures Open Interest Leverage Ratio is calculated by dividing the market open contract value by the asset’s market cap (presented as %). This returns an estimate of the degree of leverage that exists relative to market size as a gauge for whether derivatives markets are a source of deleveraging risk.
High Values indicate that futures market open interest is large relative to the market size. This increases the risk of a short/long squeeze, deleveraging event, or liquidation cascade.Low Values indicate that futures market open interest is small relative to the market size. This is generally coincident with a lower risk of derivative-led forced buying/selling and volatility.Deleveraging Events such as short/long squeezes or liquidation cascades can be identified by rapid declines in OI relative to market cap and vertical drops in the metric.
Currently, both futures and perpetual OI are at all-time highs, which increases the chances of a more volatile market, as we’ve seen over the past few weeks of an increasing amount of liquidations and deleveraging events.
Futures Open Interest Leverage Ratio. (Source: Glassnode)
Over $300m of longs liquidated
As leverage increases in the ecosystem, so does the probability of liquidation. This is supported by the metric Total Futures Liquidations, which has seen a considerable amount of liquidations in recent weeks, on Sep. 7th we saw around $70m of longs liquidated, plus $145m of longs liquidated on Aug 19th. Two of the most amount of longs liquidated this year as investors were trying to buy the bear market rally.
Total Futures Liquidations. (Source: Glassnode)
Overview of essential miner metrics related to hashing power, revenue, and block production.
The average estimated number of hashes per second produced by the miners in the network. Hash Rate 282 TH/s 8.05% (7D)
The total supply held in miner addresses. Miner Balance 1,834,866 BTC 0.05% (7D)
The total amount of coins transferred from miners to exchange wallets. Only direct transfers are counted. Miner Net Position Change -51,751 BTC -4,170 BTC (7D)
Miner capitulation isn’t over
Due to rising production costs and a mining difficulty of 1% off its all-time high we are witnessing revenues fall for miners which will see unprofitable miners switch off from the network. The hash ribbon metric is currently signalling mining capitulation is over however, Cryptoslate aren’t believing this at the moment.
With this extensive financial pressure on miners, outflows have reached peaks of almost 10,000 BTC, which is comparable with the 2018/19 bear market but not as significant as the early 2021 selling. Balance in miner wallets continues to sell off from its peak (around 15,000 BTC), however, once CryptoSlate see a meaningful reversal in miner behaviour we can become more bullish on a BTC bottom forming.
Miner Net Position Change. (Source: Glassnode)
To confirm the capitulation from the miners isn’t over. The miner capitulation tracking tool assesses the probability of a capitulation within miners, whilst it seeks a confluence between a Pull Multiple < 0.6 and difficulty ribbon compression <0.06. as well as taking the realized price for miners (excluding patoshi coins) which acts as a gauge for the mined balance cost basis, currently stands at $27,775.
Where CryptoSlate has highlighted zones in yellow shows capitulation where Bitcoin has traded below the realized price for miners. As you can see for much of the second half of 2022, we have been trading below the realized price, this tracing tool also confirmed capitulation during 2014-15, 2018-2019, and the 2020 bear market.
Miner Capitulation Tracking. (Source: Glassnode)
Collection of on–chain metrics related to centralized exchange activity.
The total amount of coins held on exchange addresses. Exchange Balance 2,371,982 BTC 27,173 BTC (7D)
The 30 day change of the supply held in exchange wallets. Exchange Net Position Change -117,735 BTC 262,089 BTC (30D)
The total amount of coins transferred from exchange addresses. Exchange Outflows Volume 247,259 BTC 12 BTC (7D)
The total amount of coins transferred to exchange addresses. Exchange Inflows Volume 257,063 BTC 5 BTC (7D)
The number of transactions signifies a bear market
The number of transactions sheds further insight into the demand for network utilization and block space. Limited available block space limits transactional capacity, and fees are used to generate a transaction. Low fees, no clear sign of traffic congestion.
During the bull runs of 2017 and 2021, it is clear to see a massive spike in the number of transactions, surpassing 300,000. However, as bull market cycles finish and bear markets begin, transactions start to fall off a cliff which is noticeable in 2018 and beginning to mid-2021. After a few months of recovery in 2021, demand has stagnated for the past twelve months, indicating this is a HODLers environment. This floor becomes the new normal until the next bull market resumes.
Number of Transactions. (Source: Glassnode)
Regional prices are constructed in a two-step process: First, price movements are assigned to regions based on working hours in the US, Europe, and Asia. Regional prices are then determined by calculating the cumulative sum of the price changes over time for each region.
This metric shows the 30-day change in the regional price set during Asia working hours, i.e. between 8am and 8pm China Standard Time (00:00-12:00 UTC). Asia 4,762 BTC -3,260 BTC (7D)
This metric shows the 30-day change in the regional price set during EU working hours, i.e. between 8am and 8pm Central European Time (07:00-19:00 UTC), respectively Central European Summer Time (06:00-18:00 UTC). Europe -15,070 BTC -3,617 BTC (7D)
This metric shows the 30-day change in the regional price set during US working hours, i.e. between 8am and 8pm Eastern Time (13:00-01:00 UTC), respectively Eastern Daylight Time (12:00-0:00 UTC). U.S. -12,827 BTC 6,027 BTC (7D)
Asia extends bullishness
Asian investors, which are considered “smart money,” have continued to accumulate since the start of September. Meanwhile, fear continues to grow in the U.S. and EU.
Asia vs. EU vs. the US. (Source: Glassnode)
The year-over-year supply continues to extend with Asia, and their bullishness is currently in line with the 2016-17 and 2020 bear markets. Asia is picking up cheap BTC during macro uncertainty.
Asia vs. EU vs. the US YOY. (Source: Glassnode)
Secondary layers, such as the Lightning Network, exist on the Bitcoin blockchain and allows users to create payment channels where transactions can occur away from the main blockchain
The total amount of BTC locked in the Lightning Network. Lightning Capacity 4,749 BTC 1.41% (7D)
The number of Lightning Network nodes. No. of Nodes 17,459 -0.11% (7D)
The number of public Lightning Network channels. No. of Channels 85,528 -0.50% (7D)
Lightning nodes and channels remain muted
As the lightning network continues to grow organically and continues to hit all-time highs week after week for August. From a node and channel perspective it remains muted, an average number of lightning network channels per node has remained flat for almost 2 years. Whilst lightning network channels opened or closed each day is considerably less compared to the bull market of 2021.
Lightning Network Mean Channels Per Node. (Source: Glassnode)Lightning Network: Opened/Closed Channels. (Source: Glassnode)
The total amount of circulating supply held by different cohorts.
The total amount of circulating supply held by long term holders. Long Term Holder Supply 13.61M BTC 0.29% (7D)
The total amount of circulating supply held by short term holders. Short Term Holder Supply 3.12M BTC -1.93% (7D)
The percent of circulating supply that has not moved in at least 1 year. Supply Last Active 1+ Year Ago 66% 0.00% (7D)
The total supply held by illiquid entities. The liquidity of an entity is defined as the ratio of cumulative outflows and cumulative inflows over the entity’s lifespan. An entity is considered to be illiquid / liquid / highly liquid if its liquidity L is ≲ 0.25 / 0.25 ≲ L ≲ 0.75 / 0.75 ≲ L, respectively. Illiquid Supply 14.83M BTC 0.14% (7D)
Illiquid supply continues to grow
Illiquid supply is defined as the total supply held by illiquid entities. The liquidity of an entity is defined as the ratio of cumulative outflows and cumulative inflows over the entity’s lifespan. An entity is considered to be illiquid / liquid / highly liquid if its liquidity L is ≲ 0.25 / 0.25 ≲ L ≲ 0.75 / 0.75 ≲ L, respectively.
Illiquid supply continues to grow through a bear market and a global deleveraging event occurring in the macro. This is an encouraging sign; even if the buyer demand is not strong, investors are not willing to let go of their BTC. Currently, 74% of the Bitcoin supply is illiquid. The illiquid supply has grown by almost 1 million BTC since the beginning of the year, currently at a staggering 14.8 million BTC.
Illiquid Supply. (Source: Glassnode)
The chart below confirms our assumption that the illiquid supply of BTC is still growing. Despite the significant drop in price this year, long-term investors’ net accumulation is still positive as more Bitcoin is being put away into “cold” storage. There has been a visible surge in coins becoming more illiquid over the last few months — 400,000 BTC — as investors move to scoop up the relatively cheap BTC.
Illiquid Supply Change. (Source: Glassnode)
Breaks down relative behavior by various entities’ wallet.
SOPR – The Spent Output Profit Ratio (SOPR) is computed by dividing the realized value (in USD) divided by the value at creation (USD) of a spent output. Or simply: price sold / price paid. Long-term Holder SOPR 0.60 -72.48% (7D)
Short Term Holder SOPR (STH-SOPR) is SOPR that takes into account only spent outputs younger than 155 days and serves as an indicator to assess the behaviour of short term investors. Short-term Holder SOPR 0.99 0.00% (7D)
The Accumulation Trend Score is an indicator that reflects the relative size of entities that are actively accumulating coins on-chain in terms of their BTC holdings. The scale of the Accumulation Trend Score represents both the size of the entities balance (their participation score), and the amount of new coins they have acquired/sold over the last month (their balance change score). An Accumulation Trend Score of closer to 1 indicates that on aggregate, larger entities (or a big part of the network) are accumulating, and a value closer to 0 indicates they are distributing or not accumulating. This provides insight into the balance size of market participants, and their accumulation behavior over the last month. Accumulation Trend Score 0.173 1630.00% (7D)
Long-term holders underwater
Long-term holders are defined as investors who have held bitcoin for more than 155 days. LTHs (blue shading) currently hold 80% of the supply of BTC, which is similar to previous bear market lows such as 2019 and 2020, as STHs capitulate due to price correction.
Currently, over 30% of LTHs are at a loss with their BTC purchases which is the most since 2020, and with a high degree of certainty, they bought during the peak of the 2021 bull run. However, this new cohort that came in during the 2021 bull run is not selling at these price levels, which only strengthens the network for the long term.
Long and Short-Term Holder Supply in Profit/Loss. (Source: Glassnode)
Long-term holders continue to accumulate
LTHs are seeing these current price levels as a time for accumulation during this “crypto winter”. LTHs buy BTC when the price is suppressed, but considering the uncertainty and macro events that have taken place this year, it is encouraging to see accumulation to this degree. Due to the significance of uncertainty for LTHs, they are flipping between distribution and accumulation with considerably smaller quantities than in previous cycles.
Long-Term Holder Net Position Change. (Source: Glassnode)
A type of cryptocurrency that is backed by reserve assets and therefore can offer price stability.
The total amount of coins held on exchange addresses. Stablecoin Exchange Balance $37.43B 1.61% (7D)
The total amount of USDC held on exchange addresses. USDC Exchange Balance $2.46B -12.75% (7D)
The total amount of USDT held on exchange addresses. USDT Exchange Balance $17.01B 1.61% (7D)
“Dry Powder” refers to the number of stablecoins available on exchanges held by investors who have acquired tokens such as USDC or USDT. The general assumption is high levels of stablecoins held on exchanges are a bullish sign for BTC as it shows a willingness to keep capital in the crypto markets until conditions change.
The chart below shows around $40 billion stablecoins waiting to be deployed, which is almost at an all-time high as participants are waiting for the macro to change from risk off to risk on.
Stablecoin Supply Ratio (SSR). Source: Glassnode
(*The chart above only accounts for the following Stablecoins: BUSD, GUSD, HSUD, DAI, USDP, EURS, SAI, USDD, USDT, USDC)